Who's Minding Miley?

By ForbesApril 29, 2008, 10:50 am PDT
Steve Granitz/WireImageForbes
Miley Cyrus, the 15-year-old star of Disney's "Hannah Montana" juggernaut, is the latest tween sensation to threaten her innocent reputation -- and give her parent company a headache -- after posing for racy photos that appeared online this weekend.

But the photos -- including one of Cyrus topless, clutching a blanket over her chest -- weren't taken by an amateur with an axe to grind. Instead, they were part of an Annie Liebowitz spread that will run in an upcoming issue of Vanity Fair. Cyrus apologized to her fans and told People magazine that she "never intended for any of this to happen."

Intentional or not, fans -- and Disney -- better get used to it. Like the Olsen twins and other stars before her, Cyrus is clearly growing up. But her risque transition from tween to teen risks alienating her core fan base, and their purse-holding parents.

Some actors, like Daniel Radcliffe, can pull it off. The star of the "Harry Potter" film series made waves last summer by performing nude in a West End revival of "Equus." The role helped to establish him as an adult actor. Others, like Lindsay Lohan and Britney Spears, haven't fared as well.

In Pictures: Tween Sensations Courting Controversy

More galleries on Forbes.com

"This is a typical issue for kids transitioning into adulthood, that their image becomes more adult," says Laura Martin, a senior media analyst for Soleil Securities. She doesn't expect the photo flap to have a material impact on Disney's revenues, despite online griping from angry parents. "Her parents are in charge of managing her reputation and should edit her image more carefully," Martin says.

Former Disney girls Lohan and Spears should have heeded that advice. Like Cyrus, both were once squeaky-clean Disney tweens. Yet by her late teens, Lohan tore that image to shreds, becoming a high-profile Hollywood party girl, adding car crashes, paparazzi battles and repeated rehab stints to her resume.

The "Mean Girls" star now draws weaker box office crowds than she did pre-publicity storm. Her campy thriller "I Know Who Killed Me" grossed a measly $7 million in the U.S.

Spears was the most famous Mousketeer since Annette Funicello when she released the single "...Baby One More Time" in October 1998. The video showed Spears, then 17, writhing in a provocative schoolgirl uniform. The album went diamond, selling 25 million copies worldwide.

Spears' incendiary videos, lyrics, and dances earned her comparisons to Madonna while her next two albums also debuted at No. 1. For a while, Spears was one of the top-earning women in entertainment. Less than a decade later, she's better known for manic behavior, questionable parenting skills and substance abuse.

With Cyrus, the stakes are bigger. Tween-focused franchises like "Hannah Montana" and "High School Musical" have become a major element of Disney's strategy as it attempts to capture the 6 to 14-year-old set as they outgrow animation-focused children's programming.

Revenue from Disney's parks and resorts, as well as its filmed entertainment, has slowed, and Cyrus provides content and a brand that can be cross-sold across different platforms, including TV, film, music, and consumer products.

Since her 2006 debut, Cyrus has had four DVDs, two CDs, video games, young adult novels, and a sold-out concert tour. Her rock-concert documentary, "Hannah Montana and Miley Cyrus: Best of Both Worlds," brought in $31 million in its opening weekend. This year, retail sales for the "Hannah Montana" franchise, which includes clothes, shoes, makeup and spa kits, is expected to reach $1 billion.

"You have to be overly cautious with a brand like hers," says Howard Bragman, a public relations executive and the author of the upcoming Where's My Fifteen Minutes?. "You don't want to risk upsetting the mothers." Bragman adds that while the Vanity Fair photos aren't risque, they're not appropriate for a brand that counts 4-year-olds among its diehard followers.

Even so, says Bragman, both Cyrus and Disney should survive unscathed. "It's a skinned knee, not a career-wrecker."
back to top

comments

comments 1-10 of 297  | newest | < newer | older > | oldest
  • Jonas lover c
    OMG! you people are sooooooooooo wierd!!!!!!!(except Vanessa ,Julia , and urbabe) how can you guys say these things about Miley?? :(
    report abuseposted July 17, 2008, 2:42 am PDT
  • urbabe
    guys don't hate miley wat if she reads this and well she could comefind u or somthing please guyz don't hate on miley my kide like her they have everything her wing so please be nice
    report abuseposted July 15, 2008, 9:40 pm PDT
  • Julia
    Miley you are such a good role model and that picture was probly pressureing but at least she isnt like vanessa hudgsens tacking a naked photo and being a %@!*#!
    report abuseposted July 13, 2008, 8:10 pm PDT
  • mileysucks24/7
    wow thats funny!!
    report abuseposted July 11, 2008, 8:24 pm PDT
  • Vanessa
    i tink tat miley isnt a whore at all!!! SHE JUS MADE A MISTAKE DOESN'T MEAN TAT SHE SUCKS NOW! NOBODYS PERFECT AND IM SURE DISNEY STAR HAV HAD NUDE PICS BE 4! I NOT SAYIN SHE WAS RITE OR WRONG 4 DOIN IT BUT SHES TALENTED AND SHE'LL BE JUS FINE! PLUS SHE IS GONNA GROW UP AND NO 1 CAN STOP TAT! LAY OFF OF HER BOUT IT! P.S. MILEY UR AWSOME NO MATTER WAT PPL SAY, KEEP WORKIN HARD!!
    report abuseposted July 11, 2008, 6:44 pm PDT
  • myleyhater
    i hate you miley, your a horrible actor and you have a horrible voice
    report abuseposted July 10, 2008, 6:38 pm PDT
  • yaj377
    when will there be a different kind-no, breed of popstars?
    report abuseposted July 9, 2008, 8:35 pm PDT
  • itsttlyme39
    this kinda annoys me.
    report abuseposted July 7, 2008, 11:51 pm PDT
  • Nani
    what a whore
    report abuseposted July 7, 2008, 4:32 pm PDT
  • Jazmine S
    OMG!! Shes such a %@!*#!
    report abuseposted July 7, 2008, 2:10 pm PDT
comments 1-10 of 297  | newest | < newer | older > | oldest

post your comment

hi there!

Want to post a comment? Just sign in and you'll be good to go.

sign in

Help us continue to improve omg! - Send Your Suggestions