Nicki Minaj, Hayden Panettiere (X17online.com/Startraks)
What they wore: A merino wool, long sleeved, stained glass print Alexander McQueen mini dress from the atelier's Pre-Autumn/Winter collection retailing at $1,195.
[Related: Fashion Faceoff: Kate Moss vs. Lady Gaga]
When they wore it: The "Nashville" star stopped by "The Late Show With David Letterman" in the form-fitting frock on August 28. The former "American Idol" judge hit the town a mere three weeks prior and practically looked like she could be Panettiere's doppelganger.
How they styled it: The "Starships" performer worked her curves in the dress and looked more demure than normal with a tame, blond wig, minimal jewelry, red pumps, and a pale pink pucker. The 24-year-old actress kicked up her heels in a pair of red booties, gold bangles, ruby red lips, and a brand new hairdo. Panettiere debuted her blond, blunt bangs and choppy cut during her appearance.
Judge's scorecard: While the looks are nearly identical, we're leaning toward giving Minaj the fashion prize. Her sleek pumps and more neutral lips accent the dress, but don't overpower it. What do you think?
More Celebrity Features on Yahoo!:
- Robin Thicke and Paula Patton Pour on PDA After Butt-Grabbing Scandal
- Sarah Silverman Pays Tribute to Her Late Dog, Duck
- Catherine Zeta-Jones Resurfaces Wearing Her Wedding Ring
- Arts & Entertainment
- Hayden Panettiere
- Nicki Minaj
- Alexander McQueen