Let's break down their lovely looks!
Kellie Pickler (Gregg DeGuire/WireImage)
Carmen Electra (Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images)
What they wore: A cotton Ted Baker dress with a flattering, trendy peplum.
When they wore it: Pickler, 26, rocked the frock at a charity event in Los Angeles last month. Her 41-year-old "Scary Movie"-star opponent wore it for a Hollywood movie premiere in January 2012.
How they styled it: The "American Idol" songstress sported suede ankle-strap Jimmy Choo platforms, a clutch, and her cute cropped coif. When Electra wore the dress, she pulled her tresses into a ponytail, slipped on peep-toe Christian Louboutin heels, put on a pair of blue Eddera earrings, and tucked a small handbag under her arm.
Judge's scorecard: Electra should step out in looks like this more often! Her shoes, her hairstyle, and the jewelry — it's the total package. As for Pickler, her strength is her sassy, short 'do, which instantly makes whatever she's wearing more chic. Still, we're leaning toward the "Baywatch" babe.
What do you think?
More Celebrity Features on Yahoo!:
- The Week's Best Celebrity Fashions (Photos)
- Tom Cruise-Katie Holmes Divorce One Year Later: So Who Won?
- Elizabeth Taylor's 8 Amazing Wedding Dresses: Where Are They Now?
- Arts & Entertainment
- Kellie Pickler
- Carmen Electra